The old piece promised a panel of men and a list of flaws. You can ignore the scorecard. People want to feel that their time was welcome. Arrive when you said, put the phone away, and ask a question you wait to hear answered.
Say what you want from the evening without a riddle. Thank them if you leave early. If something bothered you, one calm sentence is plenty. A catalogue of other people's bodies is how a date becomes a complaint.
Join free and spend that care on someone specific. The second date comes from the first one feeling decent.